Originally the island was given to Governor Lynch of Jamaica for services to the Crown and named, "Lynch's Island". Subsequently it was used by the Royal Navy (hence the new name) for a gun battery at the eastern end to complement the fort built on the mainland. After going through many hands, Errol Flynn purchased (or won it gambling) and used it for his private retreat. He planted the long row of Royal Palms which remain today as one of the most beautiful stand of such trees available. He NEVER had a home on the island but moored his yacht, "Zaca" at the island which offered a thatch-covered structure built around an existing tree. The "Governor", a local, was a full time caretaker and he lived in the only 'real' house on the island at that time. In time, Len Koutnik, a land developer from Los Angeles, purchased the island and planned an up scale vacation retreat with unusual tropical homes under the aegis, "Jamaica Islandia". Pressed by the Jamaican Government to begin some construction on this most desirable location, Koutnik was forced to lower his expectations for ultra posh accommodations. Friends in Studio City, Mr and Mrs Harry Eiler, were the first to purchase and build one of the circular homes featured on the island.
A few other hardy investors added similar homesites and finally Mr & Mrs Joseph Casey, of Rhode Island, joined with Koutnik to start construction of a hotel and surrounding rental villas. Unfortunately, Mr. Koutnik ran out of funds and, eventually, the Caseys took control of the project. However, the planned construction was never completed and only the rudimentary foundations and walls were left for years - unfinished. After Mr. Casey's death from cancer, his widow, Gertrude, offered the Eilers a lease on the entire island so that they could complete construction and operate the only private island resort in Jamaica - The Admiralty Club. After five years of operation, a disgruntled employee who was fired because he was stealing funds riled up the entire staff and took over the island. The staff commandeered the two boats used to ferry guests to the island and held the Eilers at bay until they received all their termination pay. After this terrifying experience, the Eilers left the island within a week and it was allowed to operate under local supervision by Mrs. Casey. In time, other investors became interested; however, a stipulation which required that anyone could available themselves of the amenities of the resort as if they were a guest makes it undesireable to operate as a upscale resort. In addition, there is provision for a Public Beach right amid the circle of rental villas which destroys any privacy for private use. This results in dissuading investors to proceed with the island's evelopment.
In time, the island was closed by the Government who bought out all the remaining titles and it remains today as a derelict on one of the most beautiful islands in the Caribbean. Prevalent signs that the ruins of a large Jamaican Great House were once occupied by Errol Flynn or the site of Ian Fleming are totally false. The Great House was built by Mr and Mrs William Tritt of Santa Barbara, California, and was used by the Eilers as their residence - allowing their original vacation home to be one of the premium rentals on the island. Ian Fleming never set foot on the island - although Captain Bligh did use the shallows facing the mainland as a 'careening station" (when they turn the hulls of ships to make they available for scraping off barnacles, etc) for his next command, "HMS Pandora", after the famous first attempt to bring breadfruit trees to Jamaica as a cheap foodstuff for the slaves.
Navy Beach, out on Navy Island, is accessible by ferry, which costs about US $3 per person. Navy Beach is quiet and peaceful, one of three small beaches on the island (one is clothing-optional).
Coordinates: 18°11>N 76°28>W
